Test Summary | |
Wet Braking | Pirelli P Zero |
Dry Braking | Pirelli P Zero |
Rolling Resistance | Dunlop SportMaxx RT |
Noise | Pirelli P Zero Dunlop SportMaxx RT |
Snow Handling | Hankook Ventus S1 evo2 Dunlop SportMaxx RT |
All tyres are now rated by the European standardised labels, which grades the rolling resistance and wet grip on an A-F scale. Currently no manufacturer has the technology to make an A/A rated tyre in 235/35 R19, so the best on test were the Dunlop and Continental with a "C/A". The Nokian, Hankook and Pirelli came in with a slightly worse rolling resistance score, at "E/A" and the Bridgestone and Kumho tyres graded themselves as "F/B".
The Results
Proving its sporty background, Pirelli won the test with the P Zero. Thanks to a balanced performance with a particularly strong wet result the Pirelli P Zero was the only tyre to be "Very recommended".
Second to fifth were all awarded the "Recommended" status, with the Continental Sport Contact 5P narrowly beating the Hankook Ventus S1 Evo2 to second place thanks to a slightly stronger wet performance. Dunlop finished fourth with the SportMaxx RT, interestingly the tyre was praised for sharp steering in the wet, but poor steering in the dry which seems to be a confusing mix of qualities, and the Nokian zLine finished in fifth with a balance performance, but slow steering.
In joint sixth were Bridgestone and Kumho. The Bridgestone Potenza S001 had a poor time in the wet, and the Kumho Ecsta PS91 had an even worse time in the wet, but performed slightly better in the dry than the Bridgestone.
We've included the weight measurements in the final result. The Dunlop was the lightest tyre at 8.7kgs, and the Nokian the heaviest at 9.9kgs.
The overall score is weighted 40% wet, 50% dry and 10% noise and rolling resistance.
1st: Pirelli P Zero | |
| Very high grip and shot braking distances on wet roads, good handling in all conditions, good comfort, low rolling resistance
Relatively low resistance to aquaplaning Read Reviews Buy from £153.41 |
2nd: Continental ContiSportContact 5 P | |
| High resistance to aquaplaning, good handling and short braking distances on wet roads, very good handling on dry surfaces, good comfort A relatively high noise level Read Reviews Buy from £142.99 |
3rd: Hankook Ventus S1 evo2 | |
| High resistance to aquaplaning, good handling in all conditions, low noise level Increased rolling resistance Read Reviews |
4th: Dunlop SportMaxx RT | |
| Good handling on wet roads, short braking distance on dry roads, very low rolling resistance, low noise level Relatively long braking distances on wet surfaces, slow reaction to the steering in the dry Read Reviews Buy from £131.66 |
5th: Nokian zLine | |
| A balanced performance on dry and wet surfaces Relatively weak resistance to aquaplaning, slow response to steering, rolling resistance Read Reviews |
6th: Bridgestone Potenza S001 | |
| Short braking distances on dry roads, good resistance to aquaplaning, good steering feel Long braking distance on wet roads, average handling on dry surfaces, relatively low levels of comfort Read Reviews |
7th: Kumho Ecsta PS91 | |
| Good performance on dry surfaces Poor handling and a strong tendency to understeer on wet surfaces Read Reviews Buy from £143.21 |