The biggest shock in the test is the winner - it's the brand new Vredestein WinTrac Pro. This new tyre from Vredestein proved to have Continental like qualities, displacing the Continental WinterContact TS850 P from it's usual top spot and performing well in the dry, wet and snow tests. The Continental WinterContact TS850 Pl, which has now been replaced by the Continental WinterContact TS860 S, proved that it's still a quality option and finished a very close second place.
The best of the rest was the Kleber Krisalp HP3. This Michelin owned brand have a good winter tyre reputation, and might explain why Michelin themselves weren't included in this test.
As always, details below, and be sure to check out the excellent Auto Bild website.
Dry
In the dry, all the winter tyres lagged behind the reference summer tyre. The Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3 proved it was best of the test and won dry braking, with the new Vredestein Wintrac Pro a close second.
The Pirelli and Vredestein once again performed well during the dry handling tests, but this time the Nexen WinGuard Sport just beat them to the top spot.
Wet
The key wet braking test had a new winner, with the Continental WinterContact TS850 S the only tyre to get close to the summer tyre. Vredestein again proved to be strong, taking second place, and Goodyear placed third with the UltraGrip Performance Gen-1. The Pirelli which proved to be so strong in the dry could only manage eighth place overall. The budget Sunny Snowmaster SN3830 had dangerously long wet braking.
Wet handling was the first test the summer tyre did not win, with the Vredestein, Continental, and Goodyear proving once again they have excellent wet performance.
Snow
The Dunlop Winter Sport 5 proved to be the best tyre overall in the snow testing, winning the snow braking and placing third in snow handling. The Vredestein and Continental again displayed their excellent all-round qualities by continuing their run of excellent results.
Environment
While the Pirelli struggled in the wet, it aced the rolling resistance test, using the least fuel of the group.
The Nexen proved to be the quietest tyre on test.
And the budget Sunny was significantly cheaper than the other tyres, but still not recommended overall due to dangerous wet braking results.
Results
1st: Vredestein Wintrac Pro | |
| Excellent driving characteristics on wet and snow covered roads. Dynamic balanced handling, precise steering, short braking distances and pleasant quiet ride. Test winner. High price. Read Reviews |
2nd: Continental WinterContact TS 850 P | |
| Balanced winter tyre with excellent grip in the snow, and good handling in the wet and dry. Particularly dynamic steering and short braking distances in the wet. High price. Read Reviews |
3rd: Kleber Krisalp HP3 | |
| Best performance on snow and ice, precise steering, good aquaplaning result, good comfort, low price. Slightly weak wet handling. Read Reviews |
4th: Dunlop Winter Sport 5 | |
| Excellent in snow and ice, with a balanced performance in the wet and dry too. Good steering speed and feedback, very low fuel use. Slightly long dry braking, average aquaplaning. Read Reviews |
5th: Goodyear UltraGrip Performance Gen 1 | |
| Premium tyres with excellent performance in the snow and wet. Average dry grip and dry braking. Read Reviews |
6th: Bridgestone Blizzak LM001 | |
| Good in the snow and wet, low noise. Long dry braking, high rolling resistance. Read Reviews |
7th: Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3 | |
| Good snow traction and braking, good aquaplaning, good dry handling. Average snow cornering, long wet braking. Read Reviews Buy from £189.11 |
8th: Falken Eurowinter HS01 | |
| Good snow and wet braking, good comfort, well priced. Slightly noisy, high rolling resistance. Read Reviews Buy from £144.46 |
9th: Nexen WinGuard Sport 2 | |
| Balanced handling in the snow with short snow braking, low noise. Average aquaplaning, long wet braking, high rolling resistance. Read Reviews |
10th: Sunny SN3830 | |
| Good comfort, fuel efficient, low price. Extremely poor wet grip and long wet braking distances. Read Reviews |